Weight Watchers Baked Reuben Casserole (Low-Point Comfort Classic)

Introduction — a warm, personal start

On damp, gray evenings my brain always wanders to comfort foods: something warm, a little tangy, reliably chewy and melty. The classic Reuben sandwich — corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and a creamy dressing piled on rye — has been my comfort food compass for years. Yet when I committed to Weight Watchers, I found myself staring at deli counters with wistful longing. Could I recreate that deli glow at home and still stay within my daily points?

Enter the Weight Watchers Baked Reuben Casserole (Low-Point Comfort Classic) — a layered, oven-baked reimagining that captures the crunchy, cheesy, tangy drama of a Reuben but in a lighter, family-friendly format. It’s the casserole you bake when you want to feed a crowd, pack lunches for the week, and still feel proud of your food choices. Between the steam of melted Swiss and the bright snap of sauerkraut, it smells like a deli and eats like a hug — only with fewer points. Whether you’re feeding kids, a crowd, or just craving nostalgia, this casserole is built to satisfy without derailing your WW progress.

---

Why you’ll love this recipe

• 🧀 All the Reuben flavors — tangy kraut, nutty Swiss, savory meat, and creamy dressing.
• ⏲ Hands-off comfort — assemble, bake, and let the oven do the work.
• 👨‍👩‍👧 Family-approved — kids and non-WW friends will still ask for seconds.
• 🥗 SmartPoints-savvy — portioned for control: about 4 SmartPoints per serving (Estimated).
• ♻️ Meal-prep friendly — makes excellent leftovers for lunches and busy weeknights.

---

My personal experience — the story behind this casserole

I first made this casserole on a whim the weekend after a blustery grocery run. I had leftover shredded turkey, a jar of sauerkraut, and a hunch that with a little creativity I could make something itsy-bitsy less indulgent but equally comforting. I layered the leftovers, tested a Greek-yogurt-based dressing, and slid the dish into the oven. The 30 minutes that followed felt like a slow-motion reveal: cheese bubbling, edges crisping, little flecks of rye toasting. My family walked in on that aroma and fell quiet — not the silence of suspicion, but of contentment. When they tasted it, they glanced at me like I’d done something clever, but it was simple: good ingredients, careful swaps, and a little patience. Ever since, this casserole has been my answer for cozy, low-point dinners.

---

WW SmartPoints Info (clearly stated)

• SmartPoints per serving: 4 SmartPoints (Estimated)
• SmartPoints for whole casserole: 32 SmartPoints (Estimated, 8 servings)

Note: These are Estimated SmartPoints. The real number can shift based on the exact brands you use (especially bread, cheese, and dressing). For the most accurate tracking, input your specific ingredients and serving sizes into your WW app. If you want to reduce points further, I outline swap options below and note how each affects SmartPoints.

---

Required equipment

9×13-inch baking dish

A roomy glass or ceramic dish ensures even heating and attractive presentation. I prefer glass because it browns gently and lets you check edges without opening the oven. If you only have a smaller dish, reduce cooking time and divide into two smaller casseroles.

Mixing bowls (large and medium)

One bowl for tossing the dressing and another to mix the meat and sauerkraut if you like them combined before layering. Plastic bowls are fine, but I reach for stainless for durability.

Cheese grater

Freshly shredded Swiss melts more evenly than pre-shredded slices. The texture is smoother and the melt pattern more beautiful when you grate from a block.

Slotted spoon

Sauerkraut often holds liquid; a slotted spoon (or squeezing with kitchen towels) removes excess moisture, which prevents a soggy casserole.

Foil and oven mitts

Foil keeps the casserole from drying while the flavors mingle; have oven mitts handy for a safe removal.

---

Ingredients & substitutions — exact amounts and why each matters

(Yields 8 hearty servings)

• 2 cups cooked shredded lean corned beef or turkey pastrami (≈12–14 oz cooked)
  Why it matters: The protein anchor — choose lean cuts to keep SmartPoints down. WW impact: Using lean turkey pastrami instead of higher-fat corned beef → reduces ~1 SmartPoint per serving (Estimated).
• 2 cups sauerkraut, well-drained
  Why it matters: Tang and moisture balance. Sauerkraut is low in calories and adds volume. WW impact: Sauerkraut is typically 0 SmartPoints (Estimated) on most WW plans — great for bulk and flavor.
• 1 cup reduced-fat Swiss cheese, shredded (about 4 oz)
  Why it matters: Creamy, nutty melt that defines Reuben flavor. WW impact: Swap reduced-fat Swiss → full-fat Swiss adds ~+1 SmartPoint per serving (Estimated).
• ½ cup light Thousand Island or homemade low-point dressing
  Why it matters: The sweet-tang binder that reads “Reuben.” WW impact: Use fat-free Greek yogurt + ketchup + relish instead → reduces ~1 SmartPoint per serving (Estimated).
• 4 slices light rye bread, cubed (or 1½ cups whole-wheat croutons) — optional topping
  Why it matters: Adds crunch and rye flavor reminiscent of the sandwich. WW impact: Omitting bread cubes → reduces ~1 SmartPoint per serving (Estimated). Swap for low-calorie bread cubes → small point impact.
• 1–2 tsp caraway seeds (optional)
  Why it matters: Mimics rye flavor without extra points. WW impact: Zero points; flavor booster.
• Cooking spray
  Why it matters: Helps the topping crisp without oil. WW impact: Zero SmartPoints.

Lower-point substitutions (examples):

• Swap corned beef → turkey pastrami or shredded rotisserie chicken → reduces ~1 SP/serving.
• Swap reduced-fat Swiss → fat-free mozzarella → reduces ~0.5–1 SP/serving but changes flavor profile.
• Swap light Thousand Island → yogurt-based dressing → reduces ~1 SP/serving.

All substitution impacts are estimates and should be checked in your WW app.

---

How to make Weight Watchers Baked Reuben Casserole — step-by-step

Prep: Drain & preheat

Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Drain the sauerkraut in a colander, then press or squeeze between paper towels to remove excess liquid — a small step that makes a big difference in texture. Lightly spray your 9×13 baking dish.

Layer 1 — the base

Spread half the drained sauerkraut evenly across the bottom of the dish. Sauerkraut creates a flavorful, slightly acidic base that keeps the casserole from tasting flat.

Layer 2 — the protein

Scatter the shredded lean corned beef or turkey pastrami over the sauerkraut in an even layer. If using leftover roast or shredded chicken, make sure it’s well-seasoned so each bite sings.

Layer 3 — the dressing

Drizzle half of your light Thousand Island dressing across the meat, dotting rather than flooding. The dressing glues flavors while being careful not to add excess points.

Layer 4 — cheese & repeat

Sprinkle half of the reduced-fat Swiss, then repeat layers (sauerkraut → meat → dressing → cheese). Finish with the remaining Swiss on top for a melty crown.

Topping — optional crunch

Scatter cubed light rye bread or whole-wheat croutons over the cheese. Lightly mist with cooking spray to help crisp the topping. If you crave the authentic rye aroma, sprinkle a pinch of caraway seeds.

Bake & finish

Cover loosely with foil and bake for 20 minutes. Remove foil and bake 10–12 more minutes, until cheese is bubbly and topping is golden. Let rest 5 minutes before slicing — it sets and slices nicely.

Serving tip

Serve with extra light dressing on the side and a crisp green salad to add freshness.

---

Oven / Skillet / Air Fryer variants (and point notes)

• Skillet stovetop skillet: Layer everything in an oven-safe skillet; cover and cook gently on low to melt cheese, then broil for a minute to brown the top. SmartPoints: same as the casserole if ingredients identical.
• Individual ramekins: Portion into 6–8 ramekins and bake; great for meal prep. Crisp topping under broiler for 1–2 minutes. SmartPoints: same per portion.
• Air fryer: Assemble in an air-fryer–safe dish; air-fry at 350°F for 8–12 minutes until bubbly and crisp. SmartPoints: unchanged.

---

Common mistakes to avoid

• Skipping the sauerkraut drain: This is the No. 1 cause of a watery bake. Press it dry.
• Using super-thick regular dressing: Regular dressing increases points fast — opt for a light or Greek-yogurt version.
• Overcrowding the dish: Crowding prevents even melting. Use the correct pan size.
• Cutting too soon: Let the casserole rest so it holds shape; otherwise you’ll have a gooey, floppy slice.

---

Pro tips for best results

• Toast your rye cubes briefly if you want extra crunch but less sogginess — a quick minute under the broiler works wonders.
• Make the dressing ahead — flavors meld and the tang deepens.
• Use a kitchen scale for exact portioning if you’re strict about SmartPoints — weigh the finished casserole and divide by eight.
• Double the sauerkraut for even lower points per serving (more veggies, more bulk, same protein).

---

WW-specific nutrition & strategy

This casserole is intentionally designed to be filling with fewer points: lean protein and high-volume sauerkraut keep you satisfied; reduced-fat cheese and a yogurt-based dressing provide richness without excess SmartPoints. For WW strategy, pair one 4-SP serving with a zero-point side (large salad, roasted non-starchy veggies) to build a satisfying meal that feels substantial.

If you’re planning your day, this casserole makes a great dinner on a lower-point lunch day or a weekend treat — and because it reheats beautifully, it supports flexible, sustainable eating.

---

Variations you can try (with point impacts)

• Classic Corned Beef version: Use traditional corned beef (higher fat) → adds ~+1–2 SP/serving (Estimated).
• Turkey Reuben: Use turkey pastrami → reduces ~1 SP/serving (Estimated).
• Extra melty: Add ½ cup extra reduced-fat Swiss → adds ~+0.5–1 SP/serving (Estimated).
• No-bread skip: Omit rye topping → reduces ~1 SP/serving (Estimated).
• Vegan take: Use smoked tempeh, dairy-free cheese, and vegan dressing → re-calculate points in your app; this version is typically similar or slightly higher depending on cheese substitute.

---

Tips for serving & presentation

Serve this casserole with a crisp apple and fennel salad for a bright contrast, or a big bowl of garlicky green beans for color. For gatherings, portion into small ramekins and let guests add dressing to taste. Garnish with fresh parsley to brighten the plate.

---

Storage recommendations

• Fridge: Store covered for up to 4 days. Reheat single portions in the microwave (1–2 minutes) or in a 325°F oven (10–12 minutes).
• Freezer: Freeze tightly wrapped portions for up to 2 months; thaw in fridge overnight before reheating. Texture holds up well because of the sauerkraut’s moisture.
• Best practice: If freezing, skip the bread topping — add fresh cubes before reheating to retain crunch.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Can I use canned corned beef?
A: Yes, but canned corned beef can be very salty and fatty — drain and pat dry. Using lean, sliced deli corned beef or shredded roast yields better texture and fewer points.

Q: Is sauerkraut necessary?
A: It’s the hallmark of a Reuben’s tang. Substitute with drained coleslaw mix (lightly cooked) for a milder, lower-sodium option — point impact minimal.

Q: How can I make this lower in SmartPoints?
A: Swap to turkey pastrami, use a Greek-yogurt-based dressing, and omit bread cubes — expect to reduce ~1–2 SP per serving (Estimated).

Q: Will it taste like a sandwich?
A: It captures the essential flavor profile — tangy kraut, nutty cheese, savory meat, creamy dressing — while offering a casserole texture.

Q: Can I make ahead?
A: Yes — assemble and refrigerate up to 24 hours before baking. Add the bread cubes right before baking for best texture.

Q: My casserole is watery — what went wrong?
A: Likely sauerkraut wasn’t drained enough, or you used very wet deli meat. Drain and pat dry, and consider a quick sauté to evaporate excess liquid.

Q: Can kids handle the sauerkraut flavor?
A: If kids are picky, layer a thin sauerkraut layer or chop it finer; mixing a small portion of shredded chicken with a smidge of dressing for the kids works too.

---

Nutritional breakdown (per serving — Estimated)

• Calories: 230 kcal
• Protein: 20 g
• Fat: 9 g
• Total Carbs: 16 g
• Fiber: 3 g
• Net Carbs: 13 g
• Sugar: 3 g
• Sodium: 650 mg
• SmartPoints: 4 (Estimated)

These values are estimates. For exact tracking, enter your ingredient brands and exact amounts into your WW app.

---

Recipe Snapshot

• Prep Time: 15 minutes
• Cook Time: 30–35 minutes
• Total Time: 45–50 minutes
• Course: Main / Casserole
• Cuisine: American / Deli-inspired
• Servings: 8
• Calories (per serving): ~230 kcal (Estimated)
• SmartPoints (per serving): 4 (Estimated)